Deep dive into CRA rules around using the tax-free FHSA to buy a home

Article content material

Spring and prime house-hunting season are simply across the nook, so some Canadians might quickly begin a seek for their first house.

Luckily, they will now make the most of the brand new tax-free first home savings account (FHSA) to assist pay for that house.

Article content material

For the reason that FHSA’s launch in 2023, the Canada Revenue Agency has answered quite a few widespread questions that potential contributors have been asking. Earlier than sharing a number of of them, let’s rapidly recap the FHSA fundamentals.

Article content material

The FHSA is a registered plan that permits potential homebuyers to contribute $8,000 per 12 months, as much as a $40,000 lifetime restrict, to avoid wasting on a tax-free foundation in direction of the acquisition of a primary house in Canada. The FHSA supplies contributors with a tax deduction for his or her contributions, there’s no tax on the account’s earnings and development for as much as 15 years, and it permits for the tax-free withdrawal of all contributions, funding earnings and development earned within the account when used to purchase a primary house.

To open an FHSA, you should be a resident of Canada, at the least 18 years of age and a first-time homebuyer, outlined as somebody who doesn’t dwell in a house as their principal place of residence that’s owned, collectively or in any other case, by both them or their partner or common-law companion within the calendar 12 months wherein the account is opened (previous to the house buy) or within the previous 4 calendar years.

The FHSA can stay open for as much as 15 years or till the tip of the 12 months you flip 71. Any funds within the FHSA not used to purchase a qualifying house by this time could be transferred on a tax-deferred foundation right into a registered retirement financial savings plan (RRSP) or registered retirement earnings fund (RRIF), or withdrawn on a taxable foundation.

Article content material

Article content material

This implies opening up an FHSA for qualifying first-time homebuyers is actually a no-risk proposition (ignoring any funding danger): in case you don’t find yourself shopping for a house, you successfully get one other $40,000 (plus development) of RRSP room and also you’ve loved as much as a 15-year tax deferral.

One of the widespread questions on opening up an FHSA issues conditions the place one partner or companion already owns a house.

For instance, let’s say Noah, who has by no means owned a house, opened an FHSA in September 2023 and contributed $8,000 that very same month. He put in one other $8,000 in January 2024. In February 2024, Noah married Rachel, and subsequently moved in together with her, dwelling in a apartment she has owned as her principal place of residence since 2021 (Noah just isn’t a co-owner). That very same month, Noah signed a purchase order settlement to collectively purchase a qualifying house with Rachel. The written buy settlement said that each Noah and Rachel would be the house owners of the home, and the possession date will probably be Aug. 18, 2024.

Noah and Rachel had been dwelling within the apartment that Rachel owned as their principal place of residence on the time they signed the written buy settlement to purchase their new house. The excellent news is that Noah will probably be permitted to withdraw the $16,000 (plus any development) tax free from his FHSA to assist fund the down fee. That’s as a result of for functions of withdrawing funds from an FHSA, the house possession historical past of 1’s partner or companion is irrelevant.

Article content material

One other FHSA situation the CRA lately commented on concerned a person who bought an earnings property in 2020 and rented it out to numerous tenants to earn earnings. In November 2023, when his most up-to-date tenant determined to not renew his lease, the proprietor determined to vary the house’s use and make it his principal residence. Previous to this, he had by no means lived in the home, having at all times lived along with his mother and father.

He felt he ought to have the ability to withdraw funds from his FHSA when he moved into the house since, below the “change of use” guidelines within the Earnings Tax Act that apply when a principal residence is transformed to a rental property and vice versa, you’re thought-about to have offered the property at its truthful market worth and to have instantly reacquired the property for a similar quantity.

The overall rule is that upon such a change in use, you’re required to report the ensuing capital acquire within the tax 12 months this variation of use happens (unless you make a special tax election.)

The CRA responded that based mostly on the wording of the Tax Act, the change-of-use guidelines are solely relevant for the needs of calculating a capital acquire (or loss) on the deemed disposition and reacquisition of property, and easily don’t apply to the FHSA regime.

Article content material

In consequence, the taxpayer wouldn’t be eligible to withdraw funds from his FHSA tax free upon transferring into his rental property since he had already “acquired” the house in 2020. The “change in use he made from his home as of November 2023, doesn’t represent an acquisition for the needs of (the FHSA guidelines),” the CRA mentioned.

The CRA was additionally requested about quite a lot of eventualities the place a person who has an FHSA needed to make a qualifying tax-free withdrawal to buy a house collectively, with a number of folks.

For instance, the taxpayer, a first-time homebuyer and two of his associates signed a proposal to buy a duplex in equal shares. The taxpayer will dwell in one of many two flats of the duplex as his principal residence, whereas the opposite unit will probably be rented out. The CRA mentioned the taxpayer can be eligible to withdraw funds tax free from his FHSA since “he is a celebration, with a number of different folks” to an settlement to purchase a house.

The CRA mentioned the reply can be the identical had the taxpayer as an alternative purchased a apartment along with his father in equal shares, however solely the taxpayer lived within the apartment as his ​principal residence.

Jamie Golombek, FCPA, FCA, CFP, CLU, TEP, is the managing director, Tax & Property Planning with CIBC Non-public Wealth in Toronto. Jamie.Golombek@cibc.com.

Should you appreciated this story, join extra within the FP Investor e-newsletter.

Article content material