Tax changes Jamie Golombek would like to see in the federal budget

Article content material

Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland on Tuesday will unveil the 2024 federal funds. And, whereas I’ve already speculated about what might seem within the official funds, if I have been the minister of finance, listed below are a number of of the tax modifications that might be in my federal budget.

Tax price on highest-income earners

Article content material

Our tax charges on the highest-income earners are just too excessive. With the highest marginal charges in seven out of 10 provinces exceeding 50 per cent, Canada’s highest earnings earners are contributing a extremely disproportionate share of the overall private earnings tax collected.

Article content material

Canadians reported a complete of $1.7 trillion of earnings on our collective 30.1 million private T1 tax returns, primarily based on the most recent income statistics launched by the Canada Revenue Agency for the 2021 tax submitting season. The highest one per cent of earnings earners, with a cut-off of roughly $250,000 or extra of earnings, earned 15 per cent of this earnings, but have been liable for paying 29.4 per cent of the $284 billion in private earnings taxes paid that 12 months.

Tlisted below are very sound arguments for progressivity within the tax system — that means the extra you make, the extra it’s best to pay — however as soon as your tax price will get to be greater than 50 per cent, there’s a disincentive to earn extra money since you realize you possibly can’t even hold half of what you make.

Even should you have been to argue that the highest federal price of 33 per cent is the suitable price, it kicks in manner too early, on earnings over $246,752 in 2024. Distinction that with the highest federal price in the USA of 37 per cent, which solely begins to use with earnings over US$609,350 — equal to about $834,000 in Canadian {dollars}. And should you’re, say, a medical specialist or government with mobility and may take a job in Miami, 37 per cent is the ultimate prime price of tax, since Florida is one among 9 states that doesn’t have state personal income tax on (self-)employment earnings.

Article content material

Article content material

AMT on donations

The Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) imposes a minimal degree of tax on taxpayers who declare sure deductions, exemptions or credit to scale back the tax they owe to very low ranges. In final 12 months’s federal funds, the federal government introduced that modifications to the AMT have been coming for 2024 “to higher goal the AMT to high-income people.”

Among the many proposed modifications, which aren’t but regulation, are two that particularly goal charitable giving. First, solely 50 per cent of the donation tax credit score is permitted when calculating the AMT. For donors with tax-preferred earnings, corresponding to important capital positive factors or worker inventory possibility advantages, this adjustment to the permitted donation credit score could possibly be expensive.

The second AMT adjustment is expounded to in-kind donations of publicly traded shares, mutual funds or segregated funds to a registered charity. Below the present guidelines, should you donate appreciated securities or funds to charity, you don’t pay capital positive factors tax on the appreciation once you make a present. That is meant to encourage giant charitable items and it’s been fairly profitable in doing so by offering a major profit to donors who select to donate in-kind.

Article content material

The draft AMT laws requires 30 per cent of the capital positive factors on securities which can be donated in-kind to be included in earnings for AMT functions. Since solely 50 per cent of the donation credit score is now allowed for AMT functions (as defined above), the result’s that the AMT might outcome on some important donations of publicly listed securities in 2024 and past.

These two modifications needs to be eradicated from the draft AMT guidelines to be able to encourage, not discourage, giant charitable items, which in the end profit all Canadians in the primary charitable sectors of upper schooling, well being care and the humanities.

Tax simplification

I’m including my title to the long list of pundits who’ve been calling for comprehensive tax reform. Our tax system is just too advanced. The most recent model of the federal Earnings Tax Act, which arrived on my doorstep final week, is now too giant to slot in one quantity. Operating some 2,935 pages (together with the index) over two volumes, it’s crammed with mind-numbingly complex verbiage to catch ridiculously obscure tax manoeuvres.

A place to begin for tax reform can be the elimination of most so-called boutique tax credits. This time period is utilized by tax geeks to explain authorities spending, by way of the tax system, to advertise sure packages or goal numerous segments of the inhabitants.

Article content material

Proponents of boutique credit argue that if a specific tax credit score nudges a taxpayer into socially useful behaviour, corresponding to taking public transit or staying match, then it’s worthwhile. Those that oppose such credit don’t imagine the tax system is the easiest way to attain these desired outcomes, and as a substitute encourage the federal government to institute its desired insurance policies via directed program spending.

The actual downside with the myriad boutique credit is that they’re sophisticated to manage and, much more so, to implement. In lots of instances, the hassle wanted by taxpayers to make a profitable declare can outweigh the worth of the tax credit score or deduction being sought. You might recall my personal 10-month fight with the tax man again in 2016 to get my $112 public transit credit score authorised.

Among the boutique credit are so obscure and goal such a small portion of the inhabitants that they’re hardly price cluttering up the tax kind. For instance, contemplate the Instructor and Early Childhood Educator College Provide Tax Credit score. Value a most of $250, there’s a prescribed list of durable goods that qualify for this credit score, and also you’ve acquired to hold on to your receipts in case the CRA decides to audit your declare. Solely 80,000 lecturers took benefit of this credit score in 2021.

Article content material

My resolution is to begin the tax simplification course of by scrapping most of our boutique credit and changing them with a mixture of a better fundamental private quantity (BPA), and decreasing the tax price for the primary federal earnings bracket (for earnings beneath $55,867 in 2024). This could possibly be executed by calculating the common tax profit every Canadian will get from the assorted boutique tax credit being eradicated, after which tweaking the BPA and decrease bracket price to attain a revenue-neutral outcome.

Jamie Golombek, FCPA, FCA, CFP, CLU, TEP, is the managing director, Tax & Property Planning with CIBC Personal Wealth in Toronto. Jamie.Golombek@cibc.com.

In case you preferred this story, join extra within the FP Investor e-newsletter.

Article content material